|
|
How can LEED hope to transform the building industry in an environmental mold if, to highlight the achievements of buildings, it relies on outmoded stores of value whose extraction and use does vast environmental and social harm: Silver, Gold and Platinum?
Those, of course, are the three top tiers of achievement for green buildings in the LEED Rating System. The lowest tier? Plain-vanilla "Certified." C'mon, USGBC, you couldn't pull out palladium or beryllium as a consolation prize? These tiers are also spreading a pox of heavy metals in the green building world. They've recently been spotted in the NSF-140 sustainable carpet program, and in the Cradle to Cradle (C2C) product certification program, whose founders, William McDonough, FAIA, and Michael Braungart, Ph.D., should know better.
Speaking of C2C, it was Braungart himself who suggested to me last year that there should be a more environmentally conscious tier system. His suggestion at the time was something like:
3) MicrobeI am a little (a lot) late to this conversation, but I think the only wood-burning appliances should be direct vent masonry ovens which burn at...
Am hearing about this new technology and seeing positive reviews online but have also being told that they're not appropriate for larger, older...
Hi Patsy,
This listing is just for BlueskinVP, not Air Bloc (a fluid-applied product), which we do not list. On the landing page you have...
...I would concur the irony i
...I would concur the irony is indeed rather blatant and I had wondered if color might be an efficacious representation of level, although this may not be as effective in appealing to the merchant sector...
Is this guy for real? Trista
Is this guy for real? Tristan, you should be ashamed of yourself. With all the good work being done by USGBC/LEED and organizations like MBDC with their Cradle to Cradle certification program, all you can do is ping on the names used for their rating system? What's next, an attack on the Olympics for giving out Bronze, Silver, and Gold medals?
You clearly have too much time on your hands...
In Tristan's defense (I know
In Tristan's defense (I know the guy), he wasn't being for real. This was a bit of fun. Tristan's written a fair bit about LEED here on our blog, LIVE, including two very popular posts about studying for the LEED AP test (one included a sample test that he put together), getting professionals in firms LEED accredited, a call for the USGBC to start selling a PDF of the LEED Reference Guide, and more. (He also wrote a popular Green Building Jokes post.) See them all at http://www.buildinggreen.com/live/index.cfm/2007/10/30/Tristan%20Korthal...
That said, I totally see how it could be read as a frivolous (and bizarre) attack. But it wasn't, really. Part of the thing about our blog is that it's a place to be looser and have a little bit of fun now and then. Everything else we do at BuildingGreen tends to be pretty serious and deep and rigorous... like the feature story in Environmental Building News that Tristan and Jennifer Atlee wrote titled "Cradle to Cradle Certification: A Peek Inside MBDC's Black Box." (Since that subject came up in his post and your comment.) See it at http://www.buildinggreen.com/auth/article.cfm/2007/2/1/Cradle-to-Cradle-...
Heather, I hope you continue to call it like you see it as you weave through all the red herrings, spurious claims, and just plain dumbstriking goofiness that's popping up with increasing frequency in the green building industry. It's vitally important that we all do.
I’ve been apologizing for USG
I’ve been apologizing for USGBC's heavy metal choices for years. One gold ring represents the extraction of 10 tons of rock and the emission of 595 lbs of CO2. I appreciate that the USBGC was just trying to tap into our cultural competitive spirit, but at some point we must confront the hypocrisy.
Tristan's essay may be light hearted, but the subject is serious. Janine Benyus will be at Greenbuild again this year. Perhaps we should honor her and Biomimicry with consideration of new nomenclature that represents the evolutionary development of organisms. Braungart was on target. Microbe (certified), Oak, Bee and Dolphin – this would represent an evolution of green building and honor the natural systems we claim to defend.
How about: Rock, Paper, Sciss
How about:
Rock, Paper, Scissors (salvaged of course).
Ahh, but Tristan, you have no
Ahh, but Tristan, you have not calculated the carbon impact of adopting the new nomenclature you propose! Imagine all the extra paper needed to explain the new less-intuitive approach and all the energy consumed while people sit in front of their computers trying to grasp (or remember) the new LEED levels.
For those of you who object to the Silver, Gold and Platinum nomenclature, I am starting a new carbon offset company that will allow you to purchase carbon equivalents for LEED silver, gold and platinum awards. We only accept Mastercard Microbe and American Express Dolphin.
How's this one: Good Better B
How's this one:
Good Better Best
Good Luck!